◈ Economy LabExplore the economyEvery price has a reason.
CHAPTER 11 · INFRASTRUCTURE AND INVESTMENT · STEP 1 OF 6

Everyone in Chandpur would gain more from a bridge than it costs. Why has nobody built it?

Chandpur and Rivertown have waited fifty years for a bridge across the river that everyone wants. Follow the bridge from the free rider who will not pay for it, through Nanda Builders’ contract and the traffic that does not come, to the pension fund that buys its tolls; then follow a unit of power to Meera’s pump and a crate of Dev’s fish to market. Each step opens with a puzzle and turns on one idea; every term comes after its Chandpur version, with India’s latest dated figure beside it. Capital and revenue spending, the fiscal multiplier and crowding out stay in chapter 4, bad loans and markets in chapter 8, industrial corridors in chapter 9 and the Plans in the planning chapter, and are linked; where roads, railways and power stations are is Earth Lab’s transport and energy courses.

Infrastructure (roads, bridges, power lines, water, ports) is costly, long-lived and shared, and markets supply too little of it for two reasons. If users cannot be excluded, it is a public good and each user waits for the others to pay (the free-rider problem). If users can be excluded, one network is usually cheapest (a natural monopoly), so its owner faces no rival. The answers are public provision from taxes, or private provision under a contract or regulator that fixes the price and the term.

Public good
Non-excludable and non-rival: street lights, flood banks, defence.
Free rider
Enjoys without paying because he cannot be excluded.
Natural monopoly
One network serves all most cheaply: wires, pipes, track.
Regulators
CERC and SERCs (Electricity Act 2003), AERA (2008), TRAI (1997).
Highway tolls
Fixed by the National Highways Fee Rules, 2008, revised yearly.
Harmonised Master List
DEA’s official list of infrastructure sub-sectors (first 2012).

Remember: No gate: nobody pays. A gate and no rival: one owner charges what he likes. Either way someone public must set the terms.

Spending that builds →