Pay a builder to build the bridge, or let it collect the tolls for thirty years: it is the same bridge. Why does the choice matter so much?
A public–private partnership is a long contract in which a private firm invests in, builds or runs a public asset and bears some of its risks. The models differ in who pays during construction, who collects user charges and who bears traffic risk: in EPC the government pays all and bears traffic risk; in BOT (toll) the builder finances, tolls and bears traffic risk for the concession period; in BOT (annuity) the builder finances but the government pays fixed annuities; in the Hybrid Annuity Model (27 January 2016) the government pays 40% during construction and the rest as annuities over 15 years, and keeps the tolls. When a worthwhile project cannot repay itself, viability gap funding gives a one-time construction grant (economic infrastructure: up to 20% Centre + 20% sponsor; social sectors since 11 November 2020: 30% + 30%). The rule PPPs learned after the stalled toll projects of 2011–13: put each risk with whoever can control it.
- EPC
- Government pays all; builder bears construction risk only.
- BOT (toll)
- Builder finances, operates, tolls, transfers; bears traffic risk.
- BOOT / BOO
- Builder also owns during the concession / keeps it for good.
- BOT (annuity)
- Builder finances; government pays fixed annuities, bears traffic risk.
- HAM
- 40% from the authority during construction, 60% as annuities over 15 years (CCEA 27 January 2016).
- VGF
- DEA, since 2006; 20% + 20% (economic), 30% + 30% (social), 40% pilots; ₹8,100 crore to 2024–25.
- Appraisal
- Central PPPs: the PPP Appraisal Committee (PPPAC).
Remember: Whoever collects the tolls bears the traffic risk; put each risk with the party that can control it.