Why pay people to dig a pond, when the state could just send them money?
MGNREGA (2005) gave every rural household a legal right to ask for up to 100 days of unskilled manual work a year at the notified wage. Because the work is hard and the wage modest, only those with no better option come: the scheme targets itself, and in a drought more people come without anyone redrawing a list. Cash (PM-KISAN by DBT) and rations (NFSA) reach people through lists, and every list makes inclusion and exclusion errors, worst when circumstances change. The VB-G RAM G Act replaced MGNREGA from 1 July 2026 with 125 days; as reported, most states now share 40% of the cost and allocations are fixed in advance, and whether the guarantee still expands with demand is debated.
- MGNREGA
- 2005 Act; up to 100 days a rural household a year, on demand; repealed 1 July 2026 (as reported).
- Self-targeting
- Hard work at a modest wage deters the better-off.
- Errors
- Inclusion (leakage) against exclusion (missed): tightening one loosens the other.
- NFSA and PMGKAY
- About 81 crore people get free grain (chapter 7).
- PM-KISAN
- ₹6,000 a year to landholding families (chapter 7); misses tenants and the landless.
- VB-G RAM G Act, 2025
- 125 days; in force 1 July 2026; 60 : 40 for most states and normative allocations (as reported).
Remember: A work guarantee targets itself, because only those with no better option come to dig at a modest wage, so it needs no list and grows when a drought hits; cash and rations must find the poor from a list, which leaks to some and misses others.