One committee counted 27 crore poor Indians, another 36 crore, from the same survey. Who was wrong?
India measures poverty against a line of monthly per capita consumption expenditure (MPCE) from the NSO’s consumption surveys. Calorie norms, set by a 1979 task force under Y. K. Alagh and refined by the Lakdawala group (1993), anchored the early lines; the Tendulkar group (2009) dropped the calorie anchor and priced a wider basket; the Rangarajan group (2014) priced a fuller basket again, with calorie, protein and fat norms. For 2011–12 they give 21.9% and 29.5%. Because many households sit just around any line, a modest change in the basket moves a large share of people across it; the World Bank’s move from $2.15 to $3.00 a day did the same to world counts.
- Measure
- MPCE: household spending ÷ members, from NSO surveys.
- Alagh (1979) and Lakdawala (1993)
- Calorie-based lines (Rangarajan report, 2014).
- Tendulkar (2009)
- ₹816 rural, ₹1000 urban (2011–12); 21.9%, about 27 crore.
- Rangarajan (2014)
- ₹972 rural, ₹1407 urban (2011–12); 29.5%, 36.3 crore; not adopted.
- Since then
- No official poverty line or estimate after 2011–12.
- World Bank
- $3.00 a day (2021 PPP) from June 2025; India 5.3% in 2022–23 (2.3% at $2.15).
Remember: A poverty headcount is a line laid across a crowd of households bunched near it, so a small move in the line moves crores of people; the committees disagreed about the basket, not the arithmetic.