Bansal’s spending doubles and nobody else’s changes. Did poverty rise? Did inequality?
The Lorenz curve plots the cumulative share of spending against the cumulative share of people, poorest first; the Gini coefficient is the area between it and the line of equality as a share of the triangle (0 equal, 1 maximal). The poverty headcount looks only below the line and the poverty gap at how far below; they can move without the Gini, and the reverse. India’s figures come from the NSO’s Household Consumption Expenditure Survey (2022–23 and 2023–24, the first published since 2011–12). Spending surveys miss the richest and the rich save more, so income inequality is higher than consumption inequality.
- Lorenz curve
- Cumulative share of people (x) against cumulative share of spending (y).
- Gini
- Area between equality and the Lorenz curve ÷ area under equality.
- HCES 2023–24
- MPCE ₹4,122 rural, ₹6,996 urban; with free items ₹4,247 and ₹7,078.
- Consumption Gini
- Rural 0.266 → 0.237, urban 0.314 → 0.284 (2022–23 to 2023–24).
- Survey gap
- 2017–18 results withheld (MoSPI, November 2019, citing data quality); methods changed in 2022–23.
- Income share
- Top 1% about 22.6% of national income (2022; World Inequality Lab, 2024, debated).
Remember: Poverty and inequality are different questions: the headcount looks only below the line, the Gini at the whole curve, so where a rupee goes decides which one falls.