CHAPTER 12 · c. 300 BCE – 1700 CE · NCERT · STEP 12 OF 13
How should a historian read a traveller’s account?
Travellers are best on the visible and the new: cities, walls, markets, roads, courts. They misread what they saw through their own categories or only through books: caste, land, women, slavery. Ask four questions: what could he see, how did he get his information, who was he writing for, and what do other sources say?
- Exam lens
- Mains-style: expect “how far are travellers’ accounts reliable?” and comparisons of Al-Biruni, Ibn Battuta and Bernier as observers. Use strengths (cities, markets, courts), weaknesses (caste, land, women, slavery), and corroboration.
- Strong on
- Cities, roads, markets, courts
- Weak on
- Caste, land, women, slavery
- Women
- Labour and trade missed; sati stressed (NCERT)
- Indians abroad
- Itisamuddin, Abu Talib after 1750 (NCERT)
- Al-Biruni vs Bernier
- Al-Biruni compared to find parallels; Bernier compared to rank Europe above India.
- Often confused
- Bias is a slant, not invention: a biased source can still be accurate in parts.
Remember: Strong on: cities, markets, roads, courts. Weak on: caste, land, women, slavery. Four rules: trust the visible; ask how he knew; ask who it was for; never use one account alone. Valuable and biased at once.