◆ Art LabExplore art and cultureEvery style has a reason.
CHAPTER 12 · c. 300 BCE – 1700 CE · NCERT · STEP 12 OF 13

How should a historian read a traveller’s account?

Travellers are best on the visible and the new: cities, walls, markets, roads, courts. They misread what they saw through their own categories or only through books: caste, land, women, slavery. Ask four questions: what could he see, how did he get his information, who was he writing for, and what do other sources say?

Exam lens
Mains-style: expect “how far are travellers’ accounts reliable?” and comparisons of Al-Biruni, Ibn Battuta and Bernier as observers. Use strengths (cities, markets, courts), weaknesses (caste, land, women, slavery), and corroboration.
Strong on
Cities, roads, markets, courts
Weak on
Caste, land, women, slavery
Women
Labour and trade missed; sati stressed (NCERT)
Indians abroad
Itisamuddin, Abu Talib after 1750 (NCERT)
Al-Biruni vs Bernier
Al-Biruni compared to find parallels; Bernier compared to rank Europe above India.
Often confused
Bias is a slant, not invention: a biased source can still be accurate in parts.

Remember: Strong on: cities, markets, roads, courts. Weak on: caste, land, women, slavery. Four rules: trust the visible; ask how he knew; ask who it was for; never use one account alone. Valuable and biased at once.

← Bernier Routes, courts and a timeline →