◆ Art LabExplore art and cultureEvery style has a reason.
CHAPTER 12 · c. 300 BCE – 1700 CE · NCERT · STEP 11 OF 13

How did Bernier describe the Mughal Empire, and how far was he right?

François Bernier, a French doctor at the Mughal court from 1656 to 1668, compared India with Europe at every turn. He blamed one cause, crown ownership of land, for poverty, ruined farms, “no middle state” and “camp towns”. Mughal documents and NCERT disagree: revenue was a tax on the crop, rural society was varied and towns flourished. Yet his descriptions of karkhanas, sati and trade are valuable, and his ideas shaped Montesquieu and Marx.

Exam lens
NCERT’s core traveller: expect Bernier’s comparison with Europe, his claim of crown ownership of land and its refutation, “no middle state”, camp towns, karkhanas and sati, and his influence on Montesquieu and Marx. Mains favours how far his account helps reconstruct rural society and towns.
In India
1656–68; Dara Shukoh, Danishmand Khan (NCERT)
Published
1670–71; many editions (NCERT)
Claim
No private property in land (NCERT)
Refuted
Abu’l Fazl: revenue as “remunerations of sovereignty” (NCERT)
Towns
~15% urban vs “camp towns” (NCERT)
Ideas
Montesquieu: oriental despotism; Marx: Asiatic mode (NCERT)
Oriental despotism vs Asiatic mode of production
Montesquieu’s political idea against Marx’s economic one; both built on the crown-land claim.
Often confused
Bernier is the doctor-philosopher; Tavernier the jeweller; both French, both seventeenth century.

Remember: Bernier (1656–68; Dara Shukoh; Travels in the Mughal Empire, 1670–71) · binary opposition · crown land → “no middle state”, “camp towns” · refuted by Mughal records (Abu’l Fazl) · karkhanas · sati · Montesquieu’s oriental despotism, Marx’s Asiatic mode (NCERT).

← At the Mughal court Reading a traveller critically →