Most states passed laws to protect tenants. Why did tenants end up less secure in most of them?
Tenancy reform aimed at security of tenure, fair rent (the Plans suggested no more than a quarter to a fifth of the produce) and ownership for tenants. NCERT Class 12: in most states these laws “were never implemented very effectively”; in West Bengal and Kerala a radical restructuring gave land rights to tenants. About 12.6 crore tenants received ownership or occupancy rights on about 68 lakh hectares (GoI 2007, cited by NITI Aayog 2016), but one estimate quoted by NITI suggests tenants were evicted from about 31% of tenanted land against 4% transferred to them. Restrictive laws drove leasing underground: the NSS (NSS 70th round, 2012–13) found 10.1% of operated area leased in, including 8.6% in Kerala where leasing is banned. Operation Barga (West Bengal, from 1978) recorded sharecroppers through village camps: over 65% of an estimated 23 lakh by 1993. Kerala’s 1969 amendment (in force 1 January 1970) abolished tenancy.
- Aims
- Security of tenure, fair rent, ownership for tenants.
- Fair rent
- One-fourth to one-fifth of produce (Plan recommendation, as usually quoted).
- Rights conferred
- About 12.6 crore tenants, 68 lakh ha (GoI 2007).
- Leased in
- 10.1% of operated area (NSS 70th round, 2012–13); Andhra 33.8%, Punjab 24.6%, Bihar 21%.
- Operation Barga
- From 1978; over 65% of sharecroppers recorded by 1993; effect on yields debated.
- Kerala
- Tenancy abolished from 1 January 1970; leasing later banned.
Remember: A right that needs a record protects no one who is kept out of the record.