HUMAN GEOGRAPHY · PEOPLE AND DEVELOPMENT · STEP 3 OF 14
Who is in charge: nature or people?
Three ideas describe the balance between nature and people. Environmental determinism says nature decides: early societies with little technology lived by its dictates. Possibilism says people choose: with technology they create possibilities and leave a cultural landscape. Griffith Taylor’s neo-determinism takes a middle path, “stop and go determinism”: people can go ahead when nature permits, but must stop at its red lights, because a free run brings global warming, ozone depletion and degraded land.
- Determinism
- Nature dominates; humans adapt.
- Possibilism
- Humans dominate; nature offers opportunities.
- Neo-determinism
- Griffith Taylor: “stop and go”, like a traffic light.
- Its lesson
- Possibilities within limits that do not damage the environment.
- Free run’s cost
- Greenhouse effect, ozone depletion, receding glaciers, degraded land.
Remember: Determinism: nature decides. Possibilism: people decide. Neo-determinism: people decide within nature’s limits.