THE EARTH · ORIGIN AND HISTORY · STEP 7 OF 18
What did people think about the origin of the earth?
People have long asked how the earth formed. The early ideas fall into two groups. Monistic ideas, like Kant and Laplace’s nebular hypothesis, say the planets came from one parent: a cloud around the young Sun. Dualistic ideas, like the planetesimal and tidal hypotheses, need two parents: the Sun and a passing star that pulled matter out of it. The passing-star ideas were given up. Around 1950 Otto Schmidt and Carl Weizsäcker revised the nebular hypothesis, and its modern form is the accepted model.
- Nebular hypothesis
- Kant; revised by Laplace in 1796: rings shed by a shrinking, spinning cloud
- Planetesimal hypothesis
- Chamberlin and Moulton: a passing star pulls out blobs that cool into planetesimals
- Tidal hypothesis
- Jeans and Jeffreys: a passing star raises a cigar-shaped filament from the Sun
- Revised nebular hypothesis
- Schmidt and Weizsäcker, about 1950: a solar nebula of hydrogen, helium and dust flattens into a disc
- The spin problem
- The Sun has almost all the mass but little of the spin (angular momentum); the early nebular idea could not explain it
- Monistic and dualistic
- One parent body against two
Remember: Nebular (Kant, Laplace) → passing-star ideas (Chamberlin–Moulton, Jeans–Jeffreys) → revised nebular (Schmidt, Weizsäcker), accepted today.